When I was still in graduate school, I told myself I would give the job market a few years. My goal was to find a t-t job in a place I wanted to live.
I found the t-t job. Turns out it's not in a place I really want to live.
So, this year I applied for other jobs, jobs that seemed suitable (t-t) in places I did want to live. It's looking like those jobs won't pan out, though I suppose I could get a late response. But operating on the assumption that, for whatever reason, they
weren't that into me, and following my convo. with my therapist earlier this week, I find myself thinking about this.
The period I originally planned to look for a job is over. I have a job, yes, but it isn't one I want to keep. Should I stick it out here for another year and give the market another go? Or should I decide fuck it, quit, and move back "home" this summer? Let's assume, for the sake of simplicity, that "home" is the city I got my Ph.D. in--because it is a city I like, because I have friends there, because I could almost surely find some kind of teaching gig there even if it were just picking up classes at the local community colleges until I figured out what to do next.
Reasons to move this summer: 1. Honest to god, the idea of another winter in this place makes me despair. 2. Pseudonymous kid will start kindergarten next year, and the school system back home is excellent; I was really looking forward to his being in those schools back when the possibility of not getting a job and moving seemed like a realistic one. 3. We have friends who have said we can stay with them for a bit while we're getting settled. 4. It would feel like getting on with my life; I think a big part of my depression is feeling incredibly trapped and powerless to affect my future. 5. When I imagine that decision, I feel an enormous sense of relief.
Reasons to wait another year: 1. Money. We created a pretty big debt hole, I'll get a raise next year, Mr. B. can get a job, we can build more equity in the house (and another year working on the outside--this year we're doing the inside--will enormously add to its resale value). It cost a shitload of money to move here, and the university paid for it; if the moving back costs are on me, I have no idea how we're going to swing it. 2. Fear. It worries me tremendously to think that I might pitch my career overboard after only two years doing it and only one year of looking for another job. On the other hand, of course there is no reason I can't look again next year even if we do move. More on this in the next paragraph. 3. Possibly, I might feel like an enormous loser moving back. I actually think I'd take a perverse satisfaction in going home and saying, "yeah, well, I decided I didn't want to do that"; I tend to enjoy puncturing received truths. But I can't discount the possibility that I'm idealizing the past and will find myself feeling like the loser kid who couldn't let go of her prom queen days and keeps hanging around the high school. 4. Doubt. Maybe I'm just psyching myself out; maybe I'm overreacting to the normal stress of moving across the damn country and starting my career. Maybe if I just suck it up and wait it out it will get better. But, in contrast to my feeling of relief when I imagine moving home, when I entertain this possibility the best I can get (on a good day) is a feeling of, "yeah, I can imagine staying here a year or so, I guess, and looking back on it later as a hard time in my life and a step towards building my career." On a bad day, the thought of it, as I said, makes me feel utterly distraught.
If we move, and I look for a t-t job again next year anyway, I suppose I'm in a slightly disadvantaged position since I won't be holding the title of "assistant professor" while I look. Then again, I might be in a better position if I feel like not finding a job won't be the end of my world, because I am happy where I am anyway. It's not as if I couldn't get another article, maybe even two, out while I have access to my old Ph.D. institution's (vastly superior) library, and I will probably be teaching somewhere, somehow. And I might find that teaching at a c.c. or even looking into teaching high school would appeal to me, and those options would be easier to explore if I were already in the place where I wanted to live.
The thing is, I think I would like to stay in teaching. I like it, and I'm good at it. I actually miss teaching first-year and non-major courses; my current job is "good" enough that I don't have/get to do that often. I enjoy teaching grad students; but if I never taught grad students again, that would be okay too. My research is interesting enough, and if it didn't stress me out with all the stupid tenure worry, I'd like it just fine; but again, if I dropped it, I don't think I'd feel a big hole in my life. I'd like to write something, somehow, somewhere; but I think I might prefer writing (as I prefer teaching) for a more general, less specialist audience. Furthermore, the tenure thing really annoys the crap out of me; it feels incredibly infantalizing to have finished the goddamn degree only to enter into yet *another* probationary period. The job market feels the same way: I have the qualifications, I know what I want, and I'm growing increasingly impatient with the way this career keeps us in these "student" positions where we're constantly worrying about being "good enough" and passing some mysterious set of standards, and all the goddamn power and choice is in the hands of someone else--journal editors, book publishers, the folks on the tenure committee, the mysterious job committee, whatever. It would be damn nice to have a job where I didn't feel like that, and though I'm not under any illusion that other jobs don't also require one to answer to those further along the food chain, it does seem like academia--with my worry that if I quit this job without another elusive and hard-to-land tenure-line position, I'll be essentially sabotaging my career--it does seem like academia is peculiarly fucked-up in not allowing people to shape their own careers according to their own needs.
So, honest to god, if you have any thoughts or ideas that might help me figure this shit out, let me know.